Tub was stained, room smelled like mildew, curtains not long enough to keep out street lights.

Its proximity to the Bay & free breakfast.

Stayed in August 2025

Rooms and facilities we quite outdated and not very clean. Couldn't enjoy the balcony because many spiderwebs and chairs were very dirty.

Location was nice, close to downtown. Staff was friendly

Stayed in August 2025

Parts of the property are falling apart. Our room was.clean but bathroom needs serious updating

It must have been a great facility in it's day. The staff was very friendly and helpful. We didn't need anything but they always made sure we were good.

Stayed in July 2025

A bit out dated, smelled a bit musty. Would have liked a chair in the room.

There was enough variety at breakfast. Laurie? At the tiki bar was very welcoming. Very glad they had a restaurant and (two)inside and outside bars there. Good for the traveler that didn’t want to go back out.

Stayed in July 2025

Being in a ground floor room, we checked the sliding door after spending one night and discovered it had been unlocked the first night. The security bar in the slider was also broken. We reported this to the staff and it was apparently fixed. We also discovered the shower mechanism to be very old, couldn't figure out how to use it and we ended up washing our hair by kneeling with our head under the faucet! With no grab bars, it was difficult to maneuver after kneeling in the tub. We mentioned this to the staff, and they said that there was a shower, but not one that we had ever seen before. It would be a help for future guests to have shower control instructions posted in the bathroom. The room had apparently been updated, but it was still quite dark with no overhead lighting. Dusting should also be done more vigorously. The price on the room was not inexpensive, and with the issues found, we didn't think the value reflected the cost.

We enjoyed the location of the Lodge immensely- the view of the water and docked boats from a few of the outdoor seating areas was wonderful. And, the happy hour offered in the patio outdoors was fun. The Lodge gives a discount on drinks from 3-6pm. The gardens and lawn spaces are kept up and were picturesque. I found the staff to be very pleasant and helpful. The beds were great and very comfortable.

Stayed in July 2025

The balcony was shared so that the people staying in the two other rooms were able to present themselves to the patio door. This would be great if staying with a group, but not clear from the listing. The uneasy this created was compounded by the poor quality curtains on the glass doors. The rooms were clean, but the furniture was threadbare. Bed was okay for comfort

Great location. Clean facilities. Extra blanket was readily available. They allow pets in some rooms.

Stayed in May 2025

The property is a bit worn. could use new paint and furnishings but everything was clean. Breakfast not available until 8AM. Made it tough to catch a 9:30 ferry at Northpoint, an hour+ away.

The staff were very helpful. I think in their low season, they don't man the front desk routinely. Check in was at 4PM. They called us around 3:40 to ask when we might arrive so they could be at the front desk for us. They had some home cooked cheesy scrambled eggs for breakfast that were really good. It was also very quiet. Loved that!

Stayed in October 2024

The rooms are in need of a remodel - very dated and a bit worn. We couldn't find an elevator to the second floor, had to carry every thing up stairs.

Location was great. The room was comfortable and clean. Bed was comfortable. In it's prime I am sure it was a luxury hotel. We enjoyed the common areas.

Stayed in October 2024

Had trouble with heat in room. Staff fixed that for me.

The breakfast was adequate. Plenty of room to sit.

Stayed in October 2024

Not nearly enough electric outlets

Beautiful old lodge. Young man who cooked us made to order omelettes. Lovely grounds

Stayed in September 2024

The rooms are very outdated, would be beneficial to update even the towels, but everything was clean.

Great location, cute tiki outdoor bar with food, drinks and live band, staff very friendly and helpful.

Stayed in September 2024

Bathrooms were dated and rust stained. Check in was a long process since they checked 3 of us in at the same time. Beds were dated and uncomfortable.

Location

Stayed in August 2024

Staff were friendly but not well organised / prompt taking food orders and managing a busy bar. The room and accomodation communal areas are tired and need updating. The air-conditioning in the room was the loudest I have ever experienced.

Location - being on the side of the bay with a pontoon full of boats and view of the sunset is marvellous Tiki Bar - lovely outdoor setting to appreciate the above

Stayed in August 2024

The pool wasn't really clean. The television service was HORRIBLE. sometimes you want to relax and watch TV. At this place: IMPOSSIBLE

The service was great!!

Stayed in August 2024

Water views, outside TIKI patio, inside restaurant and pub. Breakfast room.

Stayed in July 2024

Although our room was relatively clean, there was musty smell for the entire stay. The bathroom shower had mildew growing on the tiles.

The property was just across the street from the water and had a nice view.

Stayed in July 2024

Need lots of cosmetic renovations Window treatments wasn’t blocking the sunlight I like to sleep in and in dark room

Staff members at hotel was fantastic Very helpful and sweet

Stayed in July 2024

Property needs updating

The tiki bar & live music was awesome

Stayed in July 2024

Location was too remote and was dated and reminded us of the old resort in Dirty Dancing. The pool was listed as open online but was actually not operational and closed indefinitely in reality

Breakfast was good. Manager was accommodating

Stayed in June 2024

We experienced a clogged toilet, with no one around to assist except the restaurant staff. They were helpful in providing our towels and cleaning products, but we were left to unclog and clean up the overflow ourselves.

Restaurant staff were super friendly and very helpful. The accommodation itself was fine for a very short stay, and as a base to travel to the rest of Door County.

Stayed in June 2024

Bathrooms were old, grout in tile looked like it was moldy in places and the bottom of the tub was discolored.

Beds comfy and easy to find the lodge.

Stayed in June 2024

I had searched for place with a pool and the pool was closed for the season. Room was a little noisy from room above and next door.

Great location, clean, breakfast very nice.

Stayed in June 2024

Bathroom tub and fixtures were old and could use updating. Same with the carpet in our room.

The staff were very welcoming and friendly. Beautiful setting along the water on a quiet street.

Stayed in June 2024

Hot breakfast would've of made the stay perfect...

Omelets were great. Staff was awesome from bartender to the house keeper. Food was good.

Stayed in June 2024