The 3 Best B&Bs and Inns in Eleuthera Island

Based on 228 guest reviews

Eleuthera Retreat - Private Villa & Cottages on pink sand beachfront

#1 of 3 B&Bs and Inns in Eleuthera Island

Last review posted: 8 days ago

“”
“A lovely spot on one of the most beautiful beaches with plenty of space!”
“Nice with lots of potential to improve guest experience.”

Ranked 1 out of 3 in the region, as well as being 1 of for B&Bs and inns in North Palmetto Point.

The Pilot House

#2 of 3 B&Bs and Inns in Eleuthera Island

Last review posted: 90 days ago

“It was nice no complaints”
“It's was a pleasant stay had a ball”
“The perfect small-scale relaxing getaway location!”

Ranked 2 out of 3 in the region, as well as being 2 of for B&Bs and inns in Rock Sound.

Sir Charles Guest House

#3 of 3 B&Bs and Inns in Eleuthera Island

Last review posted: 312 days ago

“Arlene made sure that we had everything we needed. We rented 3 units and they were all super clean and comfortable. We w”
“I came looking for family and I found my home in Eleuthera at Sir Charles Guest House.”
“I enjoyed my stay at the guesthouse -felt very much like home. The space was cozy, comfortable and clean. Ms. Clarke our”

Ranked 3 out of 3 in the region, as well as being 3 of for B&Bs and inns in South Palmetto Point.

Guests' Choice shows you the best and most reviewed properties on top. This is based on the most important topics to our guests, like the number of recent reviews, the review score and the expertise of the reviewer.

Recent reviews

Eleuthera Retreat - Private Villa & Cottages on pink sand beachfront Review score: 10

“Perfect bolthole for 3 days. Stunning location.”
The Pilot House Review score: 10

“Just a lovely spot. The owner is very friendly, gracious, and kind. Everything was comfortable and convenient.”
Eleuthera Retreat - Private Villa & Cottages on pink sand beachfront Review score: 9

“Beautiful small cottage, only 5 in total so it felt very intimate. 1 min walk to the beautiful white sand beach. Bakery bread available via owner and good restaurant options a short drive away.”
Eleuthera Retreat - Private Villa & Cottages on pink sand beachfront Review score: 8

“The location is great, so peaceful & calm! The beach is beautiful & the cottage has plenty of space. Alexander the host is really friendly & accommodating.”
Eleuthera Retreat - Private Villa & Cottages on pink sand beachfront Review score: 10

“This stunning cottage (n°1) offers a breathtaking sea view and is just a 1-minute walk from the most beautiful beach you’ll ever lay your eyes on! Tastefully decorated, it features a cozy kitchenette perfect for whipping up simple meals. Don’t miss a trip to the Island farm, just a 10-minute drive away, for some fantastic local products! For optimal accessibility to the area, it is advisable to use a four-wheel drive vehicle. With excellent Wi-Fi, you’ll stay connected while soaking in the serene surroundings. Just remember to pack some (efficient) mosquito repellent 😜 This is the ultimate haven for nature lovers and anyone seeking peace and relaxation! If you're looking for the ultimate boat adventure, contact Captain Bubba at Fishbone Tours (he has a website) in Savannah, just a 20-minute drive away! ☺️🚤✨”
Eleuthera Retreat - Private Villa & Cottages on pink sand beachfront Review score: 9

“Amazing white sand beach just in front of the cottage. Completely preserved area. Very good snorkeling area. The nearby houses and resorts are well integrated in the landscape. There are several amazing restaurants in the surroundings at a short driving distance.”
The Pilot House Review score: 10

“There were no breakfast .just need more light on the outside”
Eleuthera Retreat - Private Villa & Cottages on pink sand beachfront Review score: 10

“perfect beach and very nice host”
Eleuthera Retreat - Private Villa & Cottages on pink sand beachfront Review score: 9

“Beauuutiful location, cute cottage, stunning beach, super nice host, check in and out very easy, we really had a memorable stay! 😊 Oh! Also, delicious pastries fresh and hot out of the oven in the morning is a big plus!!! 😋 If ever we happen to come back to Eleuthera, we will no doubt stay at Eleuthera Retreat, my husband and I 100% recommand it!!!”
The Pilot House Review score: 10

“It was nice no complaints”

There are even more property options for you

Hotels in Eleuthera Island Holiday rentals in Eleuthera Island